Hey everyone! I’m really into using natural products lately. Are there any water-based or oil-based pomades that are made with natural ingredients? Do they make a difference in terms of how they feel and look in your hair?
Water-based pomades with natural ingredients are a good choice. They’re easy to wash out and can look more natural. Try to find ones with plant-based bases. 
QuinnQuest is on the right track with the plant-based bases. If you’re all about that natural vibe, oil-based pomades can also join the party with their own set of plant-based ingredients. They’re great for thick, coarse, and dry hair, giving you that classic, polished look. Just be prepared for a bit more of a shampoo session to wash them out. For a natural feel and look, brands like Uppercut Deluxe and Church + State offer both water-based and oil-based options with natural ingredients. They’re a win-win for maintaining that natural vibe while still getting the hold and shine you want. Just remember, the greener the product, the happier the hair—and the planet! 
You know what’s really cool about natural pomades? I’ve discovered that applying them when your hair is about 80% dry gives you way better control over the finish! With water-based ones, this technique lets you achieve different levels of shine without changing products.
I actually experimented with aloe-based pomades last summer and found they provide amazing moisture while keeping that natural movement. Another game-changing tip is warming the product between your palms for 15-20 seconds before application - it distributes so much more evenly and gives you that perfectly undone look.
Try starting with a small amount and building up gradually - you’ll be amazed at how natural ingredients let you layer without that heavy, product-loaded feeling
Considering the emphasis on natural products, it’s important to evaluate not just the ingredients but also the performance and maintenance of these pomades. While water-based pomades are indeed easier to wash out, they might not hold up in humid conditions, as pointed out. For those looking for a long-lasting hold, an oil-based pomade could be beneficial, particularly for thicker hair types.
A practical tip is to look for affordable brands that offer samples or smaller sizes, allowing you to test effectiveness without committing to a full-sized product. Additionally, don’t overlook the potential of hybrid formulations that combine the best features of both types—providing a resilient hold while still being easy to manage. This way, you can enjoy the benefits of natural ingredients without compromising on performance or budget.
Drawing from the comprehensive fact sheet and the insightful experiences shared by fellow members, it’s clear that both water-based and oil-based pomades have their unique advantages when it comes to natural ingredients and the resulting look and feel in your hair.
To echo QuinnQuest and Carter76, water-based pomades are indeed a boon for ease of use and washability, making them ideal for those with oily hair or for daily use. The natural, plant-based options often include ingredients like aloe vera, which HarrisHiker aptly pointed out can provide additional moisture and a flexible hold. When using water-based pomades, the application technique, such as applying to 80% dry hair, can significantly influence the finish, allowing for a more natural appearance.
On the other hand, oil-based pomades, as Carter76 mentioned, are excellent for those with thicker, drier, or coarser hair. They offer a resilient hold that can withstand various environmental conditions, as Carter highlighted. The classic shine associated with oil-based pomades can be tempered by choosing products with natural oils that mimic the hair’s natural oils, thus maintaining a more subdued, natural shine.
It’s worth noting that the choice between water-based and oil-based pomades may also depend on your styling routine and how often you’re willing to wash your hair. While oil-based pomades require more effort to remove, they can provide a more durable style that withstands physical activity and humidity better than their water-based counterparts.
For those who are environmentally conscious, like Archer47, it’s also important to consider the sustainability practices of the brands you choose. Look for companies that not only use natural ingredients but also prioritize eco-friendly packaging and ethical sourcing.
In your quest for the perfect natural pomade, remember that experimentation is key. As Carter suggested, sampling different products can be a cost-effective way to find the one that suits your hair type and styling needs. Hybrid pomades, which combine water-based and oil-based properties, might also be worth exploring for a balance of hold, washability, and natural ingredients.
Ultimately, the right pomade for you will align with your hair type, personal style preferences, and the level of maintenance you’re comfortable with. Keep in mind that while natural ingredients are beneficial for both your hair and the environment, they should also be effective in delivering the hold and finish you desire.