Best Anti-Aging Eye Creams for Men

You’ve probably heard the expression that “the eyes are the window to the soul” a few times in your life.  The eyes are powerful.  You’ll find that many people often report the eyes being the first thing they notice in a potential partner.

Yet, when it comes to a man’s skincare routine, the eyes are often neglected.  When left untouched, the delicate skin around the eyes will develop fine lines, dark circles, and puffiness.  

But not all is lost.

The quality eye creams that we’ll be examining today can help firm skin, brighten dark circles, increase collagen production, and provide you with a more youthful and healthier appearance.

Today we’ll be reviewing several of the best eye creams for men, including familiar brands and a few new ones.

Let’s begin.

Eye Creams Compared

Ranking	Eye Cream	Size (ounces)	Active Ingredient	Targets	Form Factor	Scent	Price	Price per Ounce	Award	Rating
1	Jack Black Protein Booster Eye Rescue	0.50	Peptides, Antioxidants, Organic Omega-3	Crow’s Feet, Fine Lines	Cream	Rose, Green Tea	$40	$80.00	General Use	98
2	RUGGED & DAPPER Age Defense Eye Complex	1.00	Hyaluronic Acid, Vitamin E, Argan Oil	Dark Circles, Puffiness, Wrinkles	Cream	Unscented	$27	$27.00	For Dark Circles	97
3	Brickell Men’s Restoring Eye Balm	0.50	Lactic Acid, Peptides, Vitamin C, Hyaluronic Acid, Vitamin E, Glycolic Acid	Dark Circles, Puffiness, Wrinkles	Cream	Unscented	$40	$80.00	Most Popular	96
4	Murad Retinol Youth Renewal Eye Serum	0.50	Retinol Tri-Active Technology, Swertia Flower Extract, Hyaluronic Acid	Dark Circles, Fine Lines, Wrinkles	Serum	Light Fresh	$80	$160.00	With Retinol	94
5	Kiehl’s Avocado Eye Cream	0.95	Butylene Glycol	Dark Circles, Puffiness	Cream	Unscented	$45	$47.37	Sensitive Skin	93
6	Laneige Eye Sleeping Mask	0.80	Vitamin C, Antioxidants	Dark Circles, Puffiness, Wrinkles	Cream	Lavender	$34	$42.50	Overnight Eye Cream	92
7	Geologie Dark & Puffy Under Eye Cream	0.34	Kojic Acid, Caffeine, Hyaluronic Acid	Dark Circles, Puffiness	Cream	Earthy	$29	$85.29	Trending	91
8	Disco Repairing Eye Stick	0.34	Caffeine, Pycnogenol, Niacinamide	Dark Circles, Puffiness	Stick	Unscented	$34	$100.00	Best Eye Stick	89
9	CeraVe Eye Repair Cream	0.50	Hyaluronic Acid, Ceramides, Niacinamide	Dark Circles, Puffiness	Cream	Unscented	$10	$20.00	Affordable	88
10	La Mer The Lifting Eye Serum	0.50	Stretch Matrix Complex, Sweet Almond Oil, Watermelon	Dark Circles, Fine Lines, Wrinkles	Serum	Unscented	$74	$148.00	For Eyelids	87
11	Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Gel Eye Cream	0.50	Hyaluronic Acid	Fine Lines, Wrinkles	Cream	Unscented	$11	$22.00	Oil-Free	86
12	Dr. Barbara Sturm Super Anti-Aging Eye Cream	0.50	Biomimetic Lipids, Persian Silk Tree Extract, Red Ginseng, Hyaluronic Acid	Fine Lines, Wrinkles	Cream	Unscented	$200	$400.00	Luxury	85
13	SkinCeuticals A.G.E. Eye Complex	0.50	Flavonoids, Synergistic Peptides, Blueberry Extract, Proxylane, Optical Diffusers	Dark Circles, Puffiness, Crow’s Feet	Cream	Blueberry	$152	$304.00	For Eye Bags	84
14	Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream	0.50	Hyaluronic Acid, Retinol	Dark Circles, Wrinkles	Cream	Unscented	$14	$28.00	For Wrinkles	83
15	Every Man Jack Age Defiant Eye Cream	0.50	Vitamin B5, Myrtus Leaf Extract, Cocoa Butter	Dark Circles, Puffiness, Wrinkles	Cream	Unscented	$13	$26.00	Natural Base	82

15 Best Eye Creams For Men in 2023

Here’s our list of the best men’s eye creams currently available:

Part of the Jack Black ProSeries is this intensive all-in-one eye cream that will reduce puffiness,  fine lines, and dark circles.  This eye cream by Jack Black relies on Matrixyl 3000, caffeine, peptides, and more to provide effective results.  With regular use, expect to see brighter eyes and a noticeable reduction in wrinkles in two months.

The gentle formula is compatible with all skin types.  Lastly, the pump-top design helps to reduce waste.

Unlike other eye creams that primarily focus on fine lines and wrinkles, the RUGGED & DAPPER Age Defense Eye Complex will help to eliminate dark circles and puffiness in as little as 10 seconds.  

The award-winning formula relies on a rich blend of natural and organic ingredients, including aloe vera, jojoba oil, green tea, ginkgo biloba, and more.  Compatible with all skin types, including sensitive skin, you should have no issues with the eye cream.

Lastly, this eye cream is made in the USA.

With over 5,000 reviews, the Brickell Men’s Restoring Eye Balm is a popular eye cream specially formulated for men.  With the ability to boost collagen production and reduce wrinkles by 45% in two months.

Using a mixture of caffeine along with the collagen-boosting Matrixyl 3000, the unique eye balm will freshen the delicate skin around your eyes.  The skin-safe formula should prove to be effective for men of all ages.

Aside from delivering a rich blend of moisture and nourishment to your skin, this eye balm will also tone to provide a more even complexion.

If you like Brickell products, be sure to check out their complimentary shampoo and conditioner.

Retinol, also known as Vitamin A, is a scientifically proven skincare ingredient that increases collagen production.  By increasing collagen production, your skin will have more elasticity and firmness, which reduces wrinkles.  

Expect the silky-smooth eye serum to penetrate deep and deliver results in little as four weeks.  Aside from erasing fine lines, this eye cream will also smooth out rough skin and even lift droopy eyelids.

This USA-made eye cream is perfect for men who are beginning to show the signs of aging.

When considering eye creams for sensitive skin, go with a trusted and extensively tested brand.  When reviewing all the options, Kiehl’s Avocado Eye Cream was among the best for sensitive skin.  The gentle formula is ophthalmologist and dermatologist tested for safety while also being fragrance-free.

You can expect soothing and soft results with a rich hydrating mixture of avocado oil, shea butter, and more.  While this eye cream is a moisturizer first and foremost, it can also help to depress puffiness and darkness.  

Lastly, the formula is free of parabens, silicone, mineral oil, and artificial dyes.

Overnight eye creams provide dramatically effective and targeted results.  There is perhaps none better for overnight wear than the Laneige Eye Sleeping Mask.  The moisture-rich formula will help to erase deep-set lines while also reviving dry skin.  Compatible with all skin types, including sensitive skin, it’s a safe and gentle formula.

Additionally, the Laneige Eye Sleeping Mask includes an applicator, making it easier and more sanitary to handle.  Once you apply this mask, you’ll enjoy the cool and calming effect it provides as you go to sleep.

Founded in 2018, Geologie offers personalized skin care regimens for men.  By answering a few simple questions about your skin, lifestyle, and age, you get carefully formulated products delivered straight to your door.  

Of course, if you don’t want to go through the process of answering questions and signing up for a subscription service just yet, that’s fine!  However, if you’re testing out a new brand, consider their award-winning eye cream.  

Recognized by various men’s lifestyle sites, the Geologie Dark & Puffy Under Eye Cream works to fix your eyes in a hurry.  Formulated from kojic acid, hyaluronic acid, and caffeine, you can expect firmness to the skin along with an improved complexion.  

The simple pump design is travel-friendly and easy to use.  If you like to try new products, we think you’ll love what Geologie has to offer.

Eye sticks provide a quick and sanitary way to apply your favorite skincare product.  While the number of companies that make eye sticks is relatively small, one did stand out among the rest: the Disco Repairing Eye Stick.  

Containing all those effective ingredients you’ll find in fancy eye creams such as caffeine, niacinamide, and more, expect the Disco Repairing Eye Stick to make your eyes look better quickly. With the ability to work on dark circles, puffiness, and wrinkles, it’s a perfect all-around skincare product to have with you at all times.  

Slightly larger than your standard lip balm, it’ll easily slide into your toiletry bag when on the road.

Just because you are watching your bottom line doesn’t mean you still can’t get a decent eye cream.  If you are looking for a budget-friendly eye cream, then consider the CeraVe Eye Repair Cream.   For a modest $10, this eye cream goes toe-to-toe with some of the biggest names in the skincare industry. 

Packed with hyaluronic acid, ceramides, sweet almond oil, aloe vera, and more, it’ll deliver a splash of moisture to erase fine lines and wrinkles.  Additionally, the versatile formula will also work well for dark circles and bags.

In true CeraVe fashion, this eye cream is safe for all skin types, including sensitive skin. In addition, it’s free of fragrance and non-comedogenic.  

Lastly, the formula is dermatologist recommended, ophthalmologist tested, and even accepted by the National Eczema Association.

An eye-lifting cream can fix droopy or saggy eyelids.  However, the selection of products for targeted results specifically for the eyelids remains slim.  

If you want better-looking eyelids no matter the price, then consider the La Mer Lifting Eye Serum.  This eye lifting cream by La Mer will make your eyelids feel both firm and tight in a few weeks.  Included with the serum is an applicator with round and flat sides to ensure effective and targeted results.

If you have oily skin and are looking for a non-comedogenic eye cream that’ll leave a matte finish, then consider the award-winning Neutrogena Hydro Boost Hydrating Gel Eye Cream.  Formulated from hyaluronic acid, this eye gel cream will give your eyes a boost of youthfulness without clogging your pores.  However, unlike other products reviewed, this eye cream by Neutrogena does not target puffiness or dark circles.

The formula is free of fragrances and dyes, making it suitable for men with sensitive skin.  Lastly, for less than $13, this eye cream is a steal.

If you want the very best for your skincare needs and the price isn’t a concern, then there is perhaps none better than the Dr. Barbara Sturm Super Anti-Aging Eye Cream.  Packed full of lipids and natural ingredients, including Persian silk tree extract, red ginseng, hyaluronic acid, and more, this versatile eye cream holds nothing back.  Compatible with all skin types, expect noticeable improvements in wrinkles, dark circles, and puffiness.  

When applying this eye cream, the rich formula should absorb quickly for youthful and healthy-looking results.

If you have pronounced puffiness or bags under your eyes, you should consider a specially formulated eye cream that tackles glycation.  Glycation occurs when sugar, collagen, and elastin bind together to cause pooling or bags to the skin (source).  The SkinCeuticals A.G.E. Eye Complex contains several active ingredients, including flavonoids, peptides, and blueberry extract, to fight glycation and ultimately prevent signs of aging and puffiness.  

In SkinCeutical’s clinical study, participants saw a 29% improvement in puffiness along with a 33% improvement in skin firmness and elasticity in 12 weeks.

To effectively erase wrinkles, you should consider an eye cream that contains both retinol and hyaluronic acid.  Retinol, also known as Vitamin A, boosts collagen production, which provides a youthful appearance to your skin.  Hyaluronic acid, on the other hand, is incredibly effective at retaining moisture. When Neutrogena adds both of these ingredients together, you enjoy an effective eye cream that’ll lift even the deepest wrinkles.

Of course, given that Neutrogena is one of the largest skincare brands in the world, you can rest assured that its products have been heavily tested and widely available.

Founded in 2007, Every Man Jack was a pioneer in the natural men’s grooming space.  While they are most known for their popular natural spray deodorants and award-winning natural shampoos, their eye cream ranks up there among the best as well.

From aloe vera to cocoa butter, this eye cream by Every Man Jack provides a rich splash of moisture and nourishment to the delicate skin around your eyes.  The cocktail of natural ingredients works hard to lift fine lines while also toning dark circles.  

Lastly, the eye cream is free of parabens and phthalates.

4 Quick Tips for Buying an Eye Cream

1. Intent

Eye creams are available in many different varieties.  Some target fine lines and wrinkles, while others are for dark circles.  When making your selection, double-check that the eye cream you plan on purchasing is explicitly formulated to handle the ailment you are looking to resolve.

2. Active Ingredients

You’ll find a few common active ingredients that companies add to eye creams; here’s what they do:

• Hyaluronic Acid: This ingredient retains water effectively (source). Some estimates state that hyaluronic acid can hold 1,000 times its weight in water.  With regular application, hyaluronic acid will reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles.
• Caffeine: This ingredient is used in eye creams to depress puffy eyes, brighten dark circles, and help with skin texture (source).  
• Retinol (Vitamin A): This ingredient helps with the turnover of skin cells.  When you regularly apply retinol, you’ll reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles by increasing collagen production. Apply retinol before bed as the fresh layer of skin is delicate, thinner, and susceptible to sunburn (source).

3. Brand

When buying an eye cream, only purchase from well-known brands.  There are many low-quality products on the market that aren’t effective or safe.  During our research, we repeatedly found men experiencing allergic reactions to generic brands.  Large brands extensively test their products and are easy to contact should any allergic reaction occur.

4. What’s the difference between an eye serum, gel, lotion, cream, etc.?

As you research various eye skin care products, you’ll find that they come in many different forms, including eye creams, serums, gels, lotions, and more.  Don’t worry too much about the name as it is often only for marketing purposes.  Gel and serums tend to be clear, whereas lotions and creams are opaque.