Best Hair Dye For Men: Here’s How You Can Shave Years Off Of Your Appearance

This Article May Contain Affiliate Links

In A Hurry? Our Top Picks:

  1. Best Overall Hair Dye: Just For Men Original Formula Men’s Hair Color
  2. Best All-Natural Hair Dye: Manly Guy Hair and Beard Color
  3. Runner Up: Clairol Natural Instincts Men’s Hair Color

Right now there are Silicon Valley execs trying to figure out how to live forever.

While these billionaire are chasing the fountain of youth, the simple fact remains.

We all get older, develop a larger waste line, and of course, yes, begin to sprout some gray hairs.

To put it bluntly, getting old sucks.

But, like using a quality face moisturizer or eye cream to ward off fine lines and wrinkles, there is a lot that we can do as men to EASILY shave years off of our appearance.

And one of the easiest ways to look younger (and likely the reason you are reading this article to begin with) is to incorporate a hair dye into your monthly grooming regimen.

While we will talk about the hair dying process a bit more in detail below, we first wanted to share with you a summary of the leading products that are available for men right now:

Comparing All Hair Dyes We Reviewed

Just For Men Original Formula Men’s Hair ColorStandard16~ 1.5 months$$$
Manly Guy Hair and Beard ColorAll Natural12~ 1.5 months$$
Bigen EZ Color For MenDark2~ 2 months$$$
SoftSheen-Carson Dark and Natural 5 Minute Shampoo-in Hair ColDark1~ 1.5 months$
Clairol Natural Instincts Men’s Hair ColorStandard5~ 1 month$$$
Just For Men AutoStop Men’s Hair ColorStandard10~ 1.5 months$
RefectoCil Cream Hair DyeStandard5~ 1.5 months$
Jerome Russell Temporary Natural HighlightsTemporary41 day$$

Before You Dye: How Not To Royally Screw Yourself

When most men (myself included), get a new product in the mail we want to try it immediately.

I don’t know…maybe it goes back to the hunter/gather days of when humans would eat food before it spoils.

But anyhow, not to go off topic here…

Before you apply a single drop of hair dye to your head, its important to go through some necessary prep work.

Now I promise this won’t be painful.

First and foremost, its critical that you take a moment to look at your calendar and see what you have coming up on your schedule.  Given the semi-permanent nature of hair dye, you should never, under any circumstances, dye your hair before a big occasion.

If you plan on walking your daughter down the aisle this weekend or have a big interview coming up and want to look younger in order to compete with the new blood that is also vying for the job, just stop.

No seriously, just stop right now and don’t buy any hair dye for such an occasion.

The reason being is that hair dye, no matter the shade you purchase, is incredibly hard to get out of your hair.

Sure, if you completely waft the process and make a trip to your local barbershop with ball cap on hanging your head in shame, they will have to treat your head chemically with all sorts of crazy stuff in order to make you look semi-presentable again.

It’s absolutely paramount that you give yourself some time before you dye your hair.  We like to recommend to most men that you should give at least 3 days before any event to dye your hair.  Men playing with dyes within the 3 day window should be experienced and know exactly what to expect.

Have you ever painted a room?


Just like your standard household paint, expect dyes to dry at a shade or two darker than you expect.

So if you have medium-brown hair, we would recommend going for the light brown as it will act as a great balance between both your gray and brown hairs.

The last thing you want to be looking like is Billy Mays (god rest his soul) long lost brother after you colored your hair.

Planning The Steps Accordingly

Now when it comes to the actual act of dying your hair, you want to make sure you have everything planned out.

Put your phone away, lock the door so your kid won’t bother you, and generally make sure that you blocked off at minimum a solid hour.

You don’t ever want to be rushing through the steps of dying your hair in order to stave off any embarrassment long after you left the bathroom.

While many of the hair dyes listed in this article will contain the necessary products within the box, be sure to read the product description (we linked this for each product) to ensure there are no surprises.

To be extra safe, we would recommend the additional items as men tend to wish they had these on hand when dying their hair:

  • Trash bag or grocery bag for disposal (so you don’t stain your sink or bathroom trash can)
  • Extra plastic stir stick (just in case you drop yours down the drain or on the floor)
  • Latex gloves (Seriously, you don’t want dye getting all over you.  The ones included in the boxes are akin to what the lunch ladies used in elementary school – upgrade immediately.)

Pro Tip:  Be sure to get a standard body lotion and rub it along the edges of your hair.  This will prevent any dye from bleeding into your skin during the application process.

Are Post Dye Hair Shampoos Worth It?

In short, yes.

Color treated hair is in a word, more sensitive than traditional hair.

Not necessarily that the cuticles along the hair shaft are more prone to damage, but rather using a traditional shampoo may hasten the rate of which the dye is removed from your hair.

When using a shampoo full of harsh detergents, you will find yourself heading to the bathroom more frequently to re-apply your hair dye in order to maintain a consistent color.

Therefore, when using any one of the natural shampoos we outlined below, you should be able to stretch out the time between dye applications.

Which will ultimately save you both time and money in the long run.

Best Hair Dyes For Men

1. Best Overall Hair Dye: Just For Men Original Formula Men’s Hair Color

Gray got you down?

Need a quick color to make you look younger?

Just For Men is the leading manufacturer of men’s hair coloring products, due to their affordable quality and long lasting color. This product targets your gray hairs and gives them a boost of color, while leaving your naturally colored hair alone. This all works within 5 minutes for a fast but effective coloring job. The result is a natural looking head of hair without all of the gray.

One application gives you 8 weeks of use, or until your hair begins to grow back. Experience varies with each individual, as everyone’s hair grows back at different rates.

Most men should get a month or more with each application. Ideal for touch-ups or whole head colors, and is great for use on beards if you need a quick color. This biggest issue is that sometimes gray hairs can turn out orange after coloring, which isn’t what the product describes.


  • Lasts for 8 weeks
  • Most popular and highly rated brand
  • Works in only 5 minutes


  • None

2. Best All-Natural Hair Dye: Manly Guy Hair and Beard Color

All natural, all vegan, no chemical hair dye that doesn’t leave you irritated. This product is great for people who aren’t into harsh chemicals and metal salts found in conventional hair dyes.

Plus, this product is exceptionally easy to mix, and doesn’t need an extra developer to make the hair work. Just add water, and color! Many reviewers say that this product is fantastic, and works just as well as traditional hair colors, but without the mess.

The biggest thing you may notice is the smell of this product isn’t chemical.

It’s very organic, though there are traces of something in there that gives it a rather odd scent.

The next thing you may see after applying is that it may turn your hair shades of green, which is normal. The color should set in after about an hour. If it’s not dark enough, add more water, mix, and apply again to achieve your desired look.


  • Made from natural and organic ingredients
  • Color lasts about 4 to 8 weeks
  • Pleasant scent


  • 1-hour application process

3. Best Hair Dye Runner Up: Clairol Natural Instincts Men’s Hair Color

Clairol is a popular hair color, and rightfully so.

It features a true-to-life color that looks and feels natural. This particular color is ideal for covering up gray hairs and rejuvenating your look for longer. A full head of freshly colored hair can take years off of your look. This color gives you a nice light brown color, but if you leave it on for longer, you may find that the color gets darker.

This color doesn’t require that you purchase a developer, as it is all included in the box. This means that it is as simple as applying the product and waiting a short amount of time for the color to sink in. The result is fantastic looking hair without residual grays. This product lasts between 4 to 6 weeks with regular washing, and then you need to reapply. Works great on head and facial hair.


  • Comes in a variety of colors
  • Looks natural once applied
  • Affordable


  • May not hold color too long

4. Best Hair Dye For Beard & Eye Brows: RefectoCil Cream Hair Dye

If you need to color your beard, mustache, or other facial hair, this product is for you. It is specifically designed for small coloring jobs, and is very easy to apply and use.

You do need to purchase a specific developer to effectively use this product, and the coloring time is a lot longer than other hair colors.

It also will stain your skin, so using petroleum jelly to outline where you want to color would be wise. Because this product is only 0.5 ounces, it is just enough to use on your beard or mustache area.

It is not for coloring your hair, unless you want to buy five of these little tubes. The color lasts about 6 weeks, or until your hair begins to grow back.


  • Lasts about 1.5 months
  • Great for both hair and beards


  • Must purchase separate applicator

5. SoftSheen-Carson Dark and Natural 5 Minute Shampoo-in Hair Color

Is your hair looking like a bad remix of “50 Shades of Gray”?

Reign in unruly gray and get your hair back to its sexy former self. This hair color looks natural, and is easy to apply. The result is a soft black finish that keeps your hair’s natural look without all the mess. The formula adds in essential nutrients and moisture back to your hair, and it lasts for quite a while.

It does take a little longer for the color to set in; while the product says 5 minutes, if you want a truly dark color you may have to leave it in for longer.

Otherwise, it’s a fantastic product to color your hair black. Caution should be taken when applying, as this can dye the skin as well as cloth surfaces such as pillows and bed sheets. The color lasts a long time, and generally you won’t need another treatment until your hair grows back to gray.

6. Bigen EZ Color For Men

For gray that just won’t go away, the Bigen EZ Color in jet black offers an intense solution to rid you of your silver hues. This hair color contains no ammonia and very small amounts of peroxide, and a black color that is deep and rich like a coal mine.

It has a creamy consistency, making application a snap. No mess, no fuss, and the solution works in just minutes. You are left with a vividly dark color that is fresh and youthful.

This product is very bold, and depending on what shade you get, it may not look natural like other manufacturers. However, it is very good at getting rid of your gray hair where other products will not. Fast, effective, and lasts for weeks, this hair color is incredible as a hair dye.

Works well on hair as well as beards, mustaches, and eyebrows.

7. Just For Men AutoStop Men’s Hair Color

This product is designed to give you just the right amount of color without going overboard.

The unique applicator allows for precision while coloring, and ensures that you don’t over-color your hair. The color solution stops coloring your hair when your gray is filled in, giving you that natural looking color that blends seamlessly into the rest of your hair. It also has no harsh chemicals, making it a very gentle product.

This Autostop color lasts about 8 weeks, though if your hair is prone to growing back quickly, you could see a shorter turnaround time.

This product is designed for use on head hair, but the applicator makes it incredibly easy to apply to beards as well. Just be sure to rinse the color out thoroughly before going to bed, as this hair color can severely stain textiles such as pillowcases and bedsheets.

8. Just For Men Control GX Grey Reducing Shampoo

Stubborn gray doesn’t stand a chance against this specially designed shampoo. Just For Men is a trusted brand among men with problem areas around the hairline, and does a phenomenal job in reducing the amount of gray hair for a younger, natural look.

This shampoo specifically targets gray hairs and slowly reduces their look, leaving you with a natural head of hair that doesn’t appear to be colored at all.

This shampoo can’t be used on bleached, lightened, or colored hair. The formula used in this shampoo is designed to target your natural color, and reduce the appearance of gray while still leaving some gray hairs in for a subtle look.

It is not designed to be a cover-up or a total hair overhaul. Can be used on head hair, but works just as well on facial hair such as mustaches and beards.

Best Shampoo For Color Treated Hair

1. Sulfate Free Argan Oil

This natural product does wonders for hair that is thin, dry, and brittle. It has many different vitamins, plus the all powerful Argan Oil that revitalizes hair and makes it soft, smooth, and silky to the touch.

It helps to reduce thinning hair, using vitamins like A and E to soften the scalp and the Argan Oil helps to promote natural hair growth. This product doesn’t have harsh chemicals like sulfates and artificial colors, plus it has a very natural and pleasant scent.

This product also does not have waxes or silicone, so you won’t be dealing with that waxy outer covering that makes hair weaker over time. In addition, it’s natural composition will ensure that your freshly applied hair dye stays longer.

This argan oil product is easy to incorporate into your every day routine, and works wonders on all hair types.

2. Art Naturals Organic Moroccan Argan Oil Shampoo and Conditioner

Argan oil is a popular ingredient for shampoo and conditioner products because of its ability to promote healthy hair growth. Art Naturals is a 100% natural hair care product that makes your hair appear thicker, healthier, and longer after each use.

But it gets even better:

Men love this product because of its pleasant scent and its tried and true hardworking formula that helps to restore damaged hair back to its former glory.

The shampoo and conditioner comes in separate bottles, because unlike 2-in-1 products, this product works best when you can apply them separately.

Buying them together does work out to a higher than average price tag when compared to other comparable products, but it is well worth the price for the results that you get.

So if you have thinning hair or split ends – you should see a marked improvement from using this product. Customers have reported longer, fuller, and thicker strands after just one use!

While it won’t get rid of balding spots since it doesn’t have any biotin, minoxidil or finasteride in the formula, it will help keeping the rest of your hair very healthy.

This product is ideal for all hair types, and is gentle on skin so it should not cause an adverse reaction.

3. Re:line Biotin Hair Loss Shampoo

Rejuvenate your thinning hair with this specially formulated hair-loss shampoo by Biotin.

It features a complex mixture of chemicals, enzymes, and moisturizers to refresh your scalp and promote fuller thicker hair to help eliminate thin spots. It also uses saw palmetto to help stimulate the head and scalp.

With use, you will notice that your hair is thicker, fuller, and better looking than it ever has been. It also helps to prevent further hair loss.

This product contains no harsh chemicals: no ammonia, lye, sulfates, or sodium chloride. This ensures that you have healthy hair while using.

Made with natural ingredients and tested with real people. This product is not animal tested. By using natural ingredients, you can be sure that there won’t be any adverse side effects, such as rash or irritation. All of the reviews are incredibly positive and speak of great success while using this product.

4. BOLDIFY Biotin Thickening Shampoo

This volumizing shampoo is ideal for refreshing your thinning or balding head. It uses various solutions and chemicals to thicken the hair and reduce the appearance of thinning spots, in turn making you look much younger.

Using this product is simple; just wash your hair with this shampoo and watch as your hair becomes more full with regular use. Ideal for those men struggling with keeping a full head of hair.

This product thickens hair and encourages hair growth, moisturizes your scalp, and leaves you with fewer thin and bald spots.

Safe for use with colored and treated hair as well, as it works at the roots where the hair begins growing. BOLDIFY is not tested on animals and is entirely cruelty free. Reviewers of this product claim to see results in as few as 2 washes, which is a fantastic turnaround time compared to other products on the market that can take a week or more.

5. Lipogaine Hair Loss Prevention Organic Shampoo

This organic shampoo will jumpstart your hair growth and give you thick, luxurious locks in as little as a week. This product uses natural ingredients and DHT blockers that encourage natural hair growth while also preventing hair loss.

Caffeine stimulates the scalp, and vitamin E leaves your skin soft and supple, and both are key factors in ensuring that your hair grows thick and fast. It contains no harsh chemicals, instead going the natural route with 17 different natural ingredients. It smells great and works even better.

This shampoo is one of the better products out there, and is fast and effective at reversing hair loss and preventing further thinning of the hair follicles. Men attest to the fact that this product really, truly works, and that hair growth is noticeable after only a few uses. It is recommended that you wash with it 3 times a week for best results. Affordable and an effective product.

About Shawn Burns

Shawn Burns is the founder and senior editor of Tools of Men. He started this site with the goal of teaching men proper grooming habits and sensible style. Shawn's expertise includes in-depth product reviews and how-to articles. Shawn was recently featured in the Wall Street Journal for his expertise.

If You Thought This Was Good, Then Join Our Newsletter

When you sign up for our email list, you will receive actionable advice on how make your grooming and style regimen even better.